There’s good news for patent owners in the U.S.: more patents are surviving validity challenges decided under the Supreme Court’s 2014 Alice decision.  According to a recent study (subscription required), district courts are now more likely to decide that the patent owners possess a valid patent than they were in the first year or so after the Supreme Court’s decision, which addressed patentability of abstract ideas.

One theory for the increased strength of patents in court is that more recent cases involve patents that were written after the Alice decision and therefore were designed to withstand attacks under Alice.  This suggests that investing in preparation of patents designed to address validity issues is paying off for patent owners, resulting in stronger patents.

If this trend continues, it is likely to have a positive effect on patent valuations and on the ability of patents to have their intended deterrent effect on would-be infringers.

This development is consistent with what we have seen while prosecuting patent applications in the Patent Office since the Alice case was decided in 2014.  Overall the number of Alice-based rejections has declined and the ability to overcome such rejections has increased significantly.

We stay on top of all Alice-related developments, so if you need to file a software patent or need help with a software patent that is facing Alice rejections, contact us for assistance.





You Might Like

The State of AI in 2023

AI experienced a massive boom during the pandemic and continues to grow and shows no sign of slowing down. In fact, AI patents have had an average annual growth of…

Intro to the Metaverse

Talking about the metaverse in 2022 sounds a little like talking about the world wide web in 1985. Although still in its crawling stage, the metaverse is ripe with opportunity…